[He sees this, and it is impressive, but it's just... He can throw glowing projectiles around too, but he's not a wizard or anything. Dungeons and Dragons isn't real.]

Alright. Why?

[Ah--] Look, I'm just not sure how this is on the same level as the dreamcatcher. Someone would have to be an idiot to be skeptical about something they can see happening. I wouldn't call those feathers 'magic,' but it's hardly the same.